Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of patients at baseline and of those with valid and invalid responses to GODIN, DINE fibre and DINE fat questionnaires

From: Using postal questionnaires to evaluate physical activity and diet behaviour change: case study exploring implications of valid responder characteristics in interpreting intervention outcomes

  

GODIN

DINE fibre

DINE fat

 

Total study population (N = 832)*

Valid response

Invalid response

Valid response

Invalid response

Valid response

Invalid response

N (%)

 

349 (41.9)

483 (58.1)

679 (81.6)

153 (18.4)

616 (74.0)

216 (26.0)

Patient characteristics**

 

N (%)‡

N (%)‡

N (%)‡

N (%)‡

N (%)‡

N (%)‡

Age (years) (Mean; SD)

Mean 67.2; SD 9.53 (Range 29–91)

66.6 (9.77)

67.6 (9.33)

67.3 (9.57)

66.7 (9.37)

67.2 (9.58)

67.3 (9.41)

 

70 years and older

340 (40.9%)

138 (40.6)

202 (59.4)

280 (82.4)

60 (17.6)

247 (72.6)

93 (27.4)

 

<70 years

492 (59.1%)

211 (42.9)

281 (57.1)

399 (81.1)

93 (18.9)

369 (75.0)

123 (25.0)

Gender

Male

582 (70.0)

250 (42.9)

332 (57.1)

479 (82.3)

103 (17.7)

435 (74.7)

147 (25.3)

Female

250 (30.0)

99 (39.6)

151 (60.4)

200 (80.0)

50 (20.0)

181 (72.4)

69 (27.6)

History of MI

Yes

415 (49.9)

182 (43.9)

233 (56.1)

338 (81.4)

77 (18.6)

310 (74.7)

105 (25.3)

No

417 (50.1)

167 (40.0)

250 (60.0)

341 (81.8)

76 (18.2)

306 (73.4)

111 (26.6)

History of diabetes

Yes

145 (17.4))

58 (40.0)

87 (60.0)

110 (75.9)

35 (24.1)

97 (66.9)

48 (33.1)

No

685 (82.3)

290 (42.3)

395 (57.7)

568 (82.9)

117 (17.1)

519 (75.8)

166 (24.2)

Elevated systolic BP***

Yes

281 (33.8)

115 (40.9)

166 (59.1)

229 (81.5)

52 (18.5)

202 (71.9)

79 (28.1)

No

548 (65.9)

234 (42.7)

314 (57.3)

447 (81.6)

101 (18.4)

412 (75.2)

136 (24.8)

Elevated diastolic BP***

Yes

98 (11.8)

37 (37.8)

61 (62.2)

77 (78.6)

21 (21.4)

69 (70.4)

29 (29.6)

No

733 (88.1)

312 (42.6)

421 (57.4)

601 (82.0)

132 (18.0)

546 (74.5)

187 (25.5)

Elevated cholesterol***

Yes

173 (20.8)

60 (34.7)

113 (65.3)

137 (79.2)

36 (20.8)

118 (68.2)

55 (31.8)

No

621 (74.6)

276 (44.4)

345 (55.6)

514 (82.8)

107 (17.2)

473 (76.2)

148 (23.8)

Smoker

Smoker

117 (14.1)

48 (41.0)

69 (59.0)

85 (72.6)

32 (27.4)

79 (67.5)

38 (32.5)

Non-smoker

685 (82.3)

296 (43.2)

389 (56.8)

580 (84.7)

105 (15.3)

527 (76.9)

158 (23.1)

BMI >25 kg/m2

Yes

673 (80.9)

278 (41.3)

395 (58.7)

551 (81.9)

122 (18.1)

493 (73.3)

180 (26.7)

No

156 (18.6)

70 (44.9)

86 (55.1)

126 (80.8)

30 (19.2)

121 (77.6)

35 (22.4)

Study arm

Intervention

400 (48.1)

159 (39.8)

241 (60.3)

330 (82.5)

70 (17.5)

295 (73.8)

105 (26.3)

Control

432 (51.9)

190 (44.0)

242 (56.0)

349 (80.8)

83 (19.2)

321 (74.3)

111 (25.7)

Marital status

Married/living with partner

565 (67.9)

250 (44.2)

315 (55.8)

471 (83.4)

94 (16.6)

427 (75.6)

138 (24.4)

Single/widowed/separated/divorced

241 (28.9)

92 (38.2)

149 (61.8)

200 (82.9)

41 (17.1)

180 (74.7)

61 (25.3)

Age left school (years)

14 and under

337 (40.5)

123 (36.5)

214 (63.5)

280 (83.1)

57 (16.9)

244 (72.4)

93 (27.6)

15 to 17

335 (40.3)

147 (43.9)

188 (56.1)

279 (83.3)

56 (16.7)

257 (76.7)

78 (23.3)

18 and over

95 (11.4)

48 (50.5)

47 (49.5)

82 (86.3)

13 (13.7)

78 (82.1)

17 (17.9)

Occupation

Manual

281 (33.8)

110 (39.1)

171 (60.9)

227 (80.8)

54 (19.2)

200 (71.2)

81 (28.8)

Non manual

325 (39.1)

162 (49.8)

163 (50.2)

282 (86.8)

43 (13.2)

260 (80.0)

65 (20.0)

  1. *Total N = 832; numbers for some characteristics are less due to incomplete data; ‡percentages refer to row totals.
  2. **Baseline data; ***Elevated SBP defined as systolic blood pressure >140 mmHg; elevated DBP defined as diastolic blood pressure >90 mmHg; elevated cholesterol defined as serum cholesterol >5.0 mmol/l.